Todo · BHG-004
Useful Links — working / alternative / Wayback
Goal
Every broken Useful Links listing on Preview has a working URL, a credible alternative, or a Wayback snapshot — then an editorial keep / retarget / delete with Barbara.
Source
- 4 September meeting notes — Decision: “For every broken class — NXDOMAIN, 404, 403, TLS, 200-to-homepage — research a working link, a credible alternative, and Wayback. 403 in this context is usually ‘broken,’ not a real permission wall (Goyder cemetery named). Editorial delete vs retarget comes after that research.”
- Useful Links inventory — research pass already recorded 4 September. Casino slice is BHG-001. Remaining: retarget obvious current URLs; Wayback Cornish / RootsWeb / Leadbeater / Ships List before any delete; confirm 403s in a browser.
- 28 August meeting notes — Barbara: nine dead genealogy links; Goyder cemetery 404; shipping mostly dead (she would delete several; Emlyn wanted Wayback because Cornish arrivals matter); SE / Port Adelaide / Yorke Peninsula groups dead; History row “none of the ones they named work.”
Scope
In scope
- Apply the inventory to Preview: retarget, Wayback, or remove, following the meeting rule.
- Update the inventory when Preview changes.
- Flag rows that still need a keep/delete call, and record Emlyn’s first-shot decisions here for the group to review.
Out of scope
- The six casino hrefs (BHG-001) if that ticket is still open — do it first.
- Inventing new “useful” directories that were never on the page.
Acceptance criteria
- Preview Useful Links has no remaining casino or known-dead href from the 4 Sep inventory without a replacement, Wayback, or an explicit “dropped” note.
- Cornish-arrival / shipping rows are Wayback or retargeted before delete.
- Inventory page on the working site matches what Preview now does.
- Live on Preview. Real not touched.
Stop and ask
Do not dump the whole shipping list because it is tedious. Emlyn is taking a first shot at keep / Wayback / drop; each call is recorded below for the group (and Barbara) to review. Do not treat these as final until that review.
Decisions for group review
Emlyn, 11 September 2026, talking through listings one at a time. These are proposed editorial calls, not a meeting vote. Mechanical “same resource, new URL” retargets are not listed here.
On Preview: Useful Links. Inventory: useful-links.md.
Cyndi's List — Drop
- On the page: Genealogy, labelled “Cyndi's List”.
- Was: https://www.cyndislist.com/how-to — her general how-to directory, not the South Australia category.
- Still loads: yes.
- Meeting: dated; keep only if it earns a place. Working rule was delete dated directories unless someone will use them.
- Call: Drop. FamilySearch and Genealogy SA already cover “where do I start,” and this href was not even Cyndi’s SA list.
- Applied: off
source/11 Sep. Live on Preview 11 Sep.
Roots Chat — Drop
- On the page: Genealogy, labelled “Roots Chat”.
- Was: https://www.rootschat.com/forum/index.php?topic=158128.msg735101#msg735101 — one forum topic (
topic=158128), not the RootsChat home or an SA board. - Still loads: the URL answers, but guests get “missing or off limits” and a login/register wall (checked 11 Sep).
- Meeting: sketchy; working rule was delete one-off forum threads unless someone will use them.
- Call: Drop. A loginwalled thread is not a public directory.
- Applied: off
source/11 Sep. Live on Preview 11 Sep.
Genealogy Links SA — Drop
- On the page: Genealogy, labelled “Genealogy Links SA”.
- Was: https://www.genealogylinks.net/australia/south-australia/index.html — a third-party “over 100 links” dump, not a source we maintain.
- Still loads: yes. Mix of real destinations (State Records, SLSA, SE Family History Group) and junk, including Family History South Australia (now a casino) and RootsChat.
- Meeting: live directory; quality is an editorial call. Working rule was delete dated directories unless someone will use them.
- Call: Drop. Do not send people through a link farm that still points at the casino. FamilySearch, Genealogy SA, State Records, and SLSA stay as direct listings.
- Applied: off
source/11 Sep. Live on Preview 11 Sep.
SA 1838 Birth Marriage and Death Index — Wayback
- On the page: Genealogy, labelled “SA 1838 Birth Marriage and Death Index”.
- Was: https://www.hotkey.net.au/~jwilliams4/sa2.htm — Jenny Fawcett / Genseek transcription of BDMs as printed in the South Australian Gazette and Colonial Register for 1838. Not the government BDM office, and not Genealogy SA’s civil indexes.
- Still loads: no.
hotkey.net.audoes not resolve. - Wayback: Oct 2013 snapshot still has the full surname table.
- Meeting: not named. Working rule was Wayback unique compiled notes before delete.
- Call: Wayback. Unique one-year newspaper extract; keep the line, point at the snapshot, name Fawcett on the label.
- Applied: href and label on
source/11 Sep. Live on Preview 11 Sep.
SA Lookup List — Drop
- On the page: Genealogy, labelled “SA Lookup List”.
- Was: https://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~tigerhawk71/aus-sa_lookup.htm — a RootsWeb volunteer lookup list (people who would look things up for you), not an index of records.
- Still loads: no. Same RootsWeb freepages SSL failure as the West Briton letters.
- Wayback: Feb 2017 snapshot exists. Volunteer emails on a 2017 page are stale by design.
- Meeting: not named. Working rule was delete dated directories unless someone will use them.
- Call: Drop. Not unique compiled content (unlike Fawcett 1838). Genealogy SA and the Contact funnel cover lookups.
- Applied: off
source/11 Sep. Live on Preview 11 Sep.
Centennial Park, Adelaide — Drop
- On the page: Cemeteries, labelled “Centennial Park, Adelaide”.
- Was: https://www.centennialpark.org/ — Adelaide’s large metropolitan cemetery (Pasadena).
- Still loads: yes.
- Meeting: live; “not a Burra cemetery.”
- Call: Drop. Goyder cemetery search, Genealogy SA, and BHG’s own registers cover Burra-district burials.
- Applied: off
source/11 Sep. Live on Preview 11 Sep.
Graveyard Photographs — Retarget (Weebly)
- On the page: Cemeteries, labelled “Graveyard Photographs”.
- Was: https://headstones.gravesecrets.net/index.html — TLS dead.
- Same project now: https://headstones.weebly.com/ — statewide SA headstone photos. Index includes Burra, Booborowie, Baldina, Hallett, Farrell Flat, Terowie, Whyte-Yarcowie. Some cemeteries say photos are not available. Inventory note: paid photos.
- Meeting: not named. BHG already has its own headstone pages (1970–1999) further down Resources.
- Call: Retarget to Weebly. Burra-district cemeteries earn a place; the old host is what failed.
- Applied: href on
source/11 Sep. Live on Preview 11 Sep.
Gould Genealogy — Drop
- On the page: History & Genealogy Bookstores — the only listing under that heading.
- Was: https://www.gould.com.au/ — a commercial genealogy shop. Checker got Cloudflare 403; inventory treated the shop as still live.
- Meeting: the rebuild is for a site that is no longer selling.
- Call: Drop. A shop on a site that does not sell is leftover from the old Resources dump. The empty Bookstores heading and its mini-nav line come off with it.
- Applied: off
source/11 Sep (heading and#booksnav too). Live on Preview 11 Sep.
1878 Lusitania — Retarget (GENUKI)
- On the page: Shipping, labelled “1878 Lusitania (single male passengers)”.
- Was: https://www.genuki.org.uk/big/Indexes/PassengerLists/Lusitania.html — 404.
- Same list now: https://www.genuki.org.uk/big/MerchantMarine/Lusitania — George Bell’s transcription; single male emigrants, Plymouth 1 July 1878, Adelaide 38 days later.
- Meeting: Barbara would delete several shipping lines; Emlyn wanted Wayback first because Cornish arrivals matter. Working rule: do not dump the whole shipping list because it is tedious. This list is not Cornish-arrival material.
- Call: Retarget. The compiled passenger list still exists at a new GENUKI path.
- Applied: href on
source/11 Sep. Live on Preview 11 Sep.
1841 Sailing Ship India — Keep
- On the page: Shipping, labelled “1841 Sailing Ship India (lost at sea)”.
- Is: https://barronfamilyuk.weebly.com/the-india.html — Barron family Weebly. Barque India left Greenock 4 June 1841 with bounty immigrants for Port Phillip, burned in the Atlantic; survivors via Rio on the Grindlay to Port Phillip (Melbourne), not Adelaide.
- Still loads: yes.
- Meeting: not named. Not an SA passenger directory.
- Call: Keep. Interesting compiled shipwreck notes. Label updated to say Port Phillip so it is not mistaken for an Adelaide arrival.
- Applied: label on
source/11 Sep. Href unchanged. Live on Preview 11 Sep.
The Ships List — 1847–1886 — Wayback
- On the page: Shipping, labelled “The Ships List - 1847-1886”.
- Was: https://www.theshipslist.com/ships/australia/SAassistedindex.shtml — Robert Janmaat / TheShipsList transcripts of SA assisted arrivals. DNS is dead.
- Wayback: Apr 2024 snapshot still has the index.
- Meeting: Wayback Cornish / Ships List before any delete. Official lists (Bound for SA, Passengers in History) are not the same transcripts.
- Call: Wayback. Unique compiled notes, dead host — same rule as Fawcett 1838.
- Applied: href on
source/11 Sep. Live on Preview 11 Sep.
West Briton letters (three lines) — Wayback
- On the page: Useful Sites for Burra and Surrounding Districts, under “Burra in the West Briton Newspaper”.
- Was: RootsWeb freepages (
~wbritonad) — West Briton (Cornwall) letters about Burra: W. Trelow 1850 emigration; W. H. Boase 1853 news; 1850 mining. Live host fails SSL. - Wayback: Emigration letter has a Mar 2011 snapshot. The other two had no dedicated 200 from the availability API; they point at Wayback 2011 nearest-capture URLs for the same original paths.
- Meeting: Cornish letters matter; Wayback before drop.
- Call: Wayback all three. Same compiled notes, same dead host.
- Applied: hrefs on
source/11 Sep. Live on Preview 11 Sep.
Burra Fossil Experience — Both (VIC current + Wayback original)
- On the page: History, labelled “Burra Fossil Experience”.
- Was: SA Museum PDF — Sam Arman, Burra Megafauna Revisited. 404. Not the same as current Arman work (Naracoorte kangaroos).
- Wayback original: Jul 2019 snapshot of that PDF.
- Current VIC page: burravisitorcentre.com/our-town-burra/megafauna — Rod Wells / Baldina–Red Banks visitor interpretation. Different document, same Burra megafauna story.
- Call: Both. Keep the archived Arman handout and add the living VIC page as a second line.
- Applied: two listings on
source/11 Sep. Live on Preview 11 Sep.
Southern Eyre Peninsula Family History Group — Keep and relabel
- On the page: Family History Groups, labelled “Southern Eyre Peninsula Family History Group”.
- Was: mangled SA Community URL with
%2526. Organisation now titles itself Port Lincoln History Group (SA Community still says “formerly Southern Eyre Peninsula Family & Local History Group Inc.”). - Current site: portlincolnhistory.au/port-lincoln-history-group — History Centre / Mill Cottage Museum, Port Lincoln.
- Call: Keep and relabel. Point at their own site; keep the old name in parentheses so the group can still find it.
- Applied: label and href on
source/11 Sep. Live on Preview 11 Sep.
South Australians Serving in the Boer War — Keep and fix label
- On the page: History. Label was truncated in the HTML (“Boer Wa” plus a stray “r”).
- Is: Findmypast article — SA Boer War contingents. Live. Findmypast is commercial/paywalled for the records behind the article. AWM is already on War Memorials.
- Call: Keep and fix the label. Named SA contingents list; paywall is the same class as Genealogy SA’s databases.
- Applied: label on
source/11 Sep. Href unchanged. Live on Preview 11 Sep.
Burra Visitors Information Centre — Keep and add href
- On the page: Useful Sites for Burra and Surrounding Districts — first line, no href.
- Current site: https://visitburra.com.au/ — Burra & Goyder VIC, 2 Market Square. Same host as the megafauna page just added.
- Call: Keep and add that href.
- Applied: href on
source/11 Sep. Live on Preview 11 Sep.
Cemetery Records and Transcriptions — Point at #data
- On the page: Cemeteries — no href. Not a missing external.
- Is: BHG’s own registers further down the same Resources page (
#data): cemetery 1858–1899, 1900–1988, headstones 1970–1999. - Call: Point at
#data. Same page, our own work. - Applied: href
#dataonsource/11 Sep. Live on Preview 11 Sep.
Burra War Memorial — Point at Fallen Soldiers
- On the page: War Memorials — no href.
- On this site: Fallen Soldiers War Memorial.
- Call: Point at the on-site Fallen Soldiers page. VWMA can wait for the mechanical RSL→VWMA retarget.
- Applied: href on
source/11 Sep. Live on Preview 11 Sep.
Mechanical retargets (same resource, new URL)
Applied on source/ 11 September 2026 after browser confirmation of the old 403s. Not editorial keep/drop calls. Live on Preview 11 Sep.
| Listing | Now points at |
|---|---|
| SA Deaths & Burials cemetery index | Genealogy SA online-database-search |
| Registrar of Births Deaths and Marriages | NLA family-history BDM guide (SA section still on that page) |
| State Records of South Australia | Same home URL — loads in a browser |
| Family history research (was “SA Family Trees”) | archives.sa.gov.au/finding-information/family-history-research |
| National Archives of Australia | /explore-collection |
| Goyder cemetery records | /services/cemeteries/cemetery-records |
| Cemeteries SA | OzGenOnline SA index (http://www.ozgenonline.com/~australian_cemeteries/sa/index.htm) |
| Bound for South Australia | SLSA collections — Diane Cummings |
| SA Shipping | perthdps.com/shipping/mig-sa1.htm |
| Burra Community Library | OneCard Burra |
| State Library of SA | /home |
| South East Family History Group | http://www.sefhg.org/ (HTTPS fails; HTTP page updated 15 May 2026) |
| Port Adelaide Historical Society | portadelaide.org |
| Yorke Peninsula Family History Group | Genealogy SA branch page |
| Heritage SA | SA Heritage Register |
| Australasian Mining History Association | mininghistory.asn.au |
| South Australians at War | SLSA digital collections saatwar |
| Virtual War Memorial Australia (was RSL / “War Memorials in Australia”) | vwma.org.au |
| Destitute Women | closing parenthesis moved inside the link |
| Australia ICOMOS | label only (href already live) |
Browser-checked 11 Sep (the 4 Sep checker 403s): State Records home, State Records family history, Goyder cemetery records, OneCard Burra catalogue, VWMA home. All load.
Check on Preview
- Resources → Useful Links — no Cyndi’s List, Roots Chat, Genealogy Links SA, SA Lookup List, Centennial Park, Gould / Bookstores heading, or live
familyhistorysa.orghrefs. - Genealogy — Fawcett 1838 is Wayback; deaths/burials → Genealogy SA database search; Registrar → NLA BDM guide; Destitute parenthesis closed; Family history research (State Records); NAA
/explore-collection. - Cemeteries — Goyder current path; OzGenOnline SA; Graveyard Photographs → Weebly; on-site
#data. - Shipping — Bound for SA collections URL; Ships List Wayback; Perth DPS; Lusitania GENUKI; India labelled Port Phillip.
- Libraries — OneCard Burra; SLSA
/home. - Family History Groups — Port Lincoln History Group; SEFHG HTTP; Port Adelaide; Yorke Peninsula via Genealogy SA.
- History — Heritage Register; AMHA; VIC megafauna + Wayback Arman; SLSA saatwar.
- War Memorials — VWMA; Burra War Memorial → Fallen Soldiers; Australia ICOMOS.
Completion notes
Published to Preview 11 September 2026 (bhgsite2026 source/resources/index.html). Real not touched.
Emlyn’s keep / drop / Wayback / retarget calls are on this ticket for group review — proposed, not a meeting vote. Mechanical same-resource URL updates applied in the same slice. 4 Sep checker 403s (State Records, Goyder, OneCard, VWMA) load in a browser.
Inventory updated to match Preview. Working Todo Check link is Useful Links.